In September 2020 – just days after the 35th anniversary of Super Mario Bros. – Nintendo’s legal team finally moved. They issued a DMCA takedown notice against all copies of Peach’s Untold Tale . The notice cited copyright infringement, arguing that even as a parody, the game went far beyond fair use by directly copying Nintendo’s characters and worlds for explicit content.
If you wish to experience this piece of internet history:
This public link is valid for 7 days and shares a thread, including any personal information you added. This link or copies made by others cannot be deleted. If you share with third parties, their policies apply. Can’t copy the link right now. Try again later. In September 2020 – just days after the
The categorization of underground Flash files under "Lifestyle and Entertainment" highlights a broader cultural trend. For a generation of internet users, interacting with, archiving, and modding classic gaming assets was a primary form of digital entertainment.
[ Classic Nintendo Formula ] --> [ Peach's Untold Tale Parody ] - Mario saves Princess Peach. - Mario is missing entirely. - Linear platforming gameplay. - Interactive adult RPG elements. - Family-friendly progression. - Sandbox progression mechanics. The Role of Swfchan and File "215302" The notice cited copyright infringement, arguing that even
: The ongoing friction between developers creating transformative parodies and corporations issuing DMCA notices remains a foundational debate in modern copyright law.
The project is structured as a 2D action-platformer with RPG elements. It incorporates exploration and interactive dialogue systems that were complex for the Flash medium at the time. If you share with third parties, their policies apply
The developer’s GitHub page was taken down, replaced by a stark message: “The copyrighted works are characters and audio‑visual works of Nintendo and its Super Mario franchise.” . Just weeks before the takedown, Aedler had posted on his Patreon that he would “rather be dead than abandon” the project. But Nintendo’s army of lawyers didn’t care. In a matter of days, a project that had been quietly evolving for eight years was erased from mainstream repositories, including Newgrounds and GitHub.